Macaulay honored as IHSAA All District Coach of the Year

By Dennis Marshall
Natalie Macaulay had a pretty good idea why she’d been invited to the Indiana High School Volleyball Coaches Association’s state finals banquet. The program confirmed her suspicions.
After guiding North Posey to sectional and regional championships and its first semistate appearance since 2021, Macaulay was named the association’s 2026 Class 2A South All-District Coach of the Year.
Macaulay learned of the recognition Nov. 6 in Indianapolis, where she was attending the banquet for the first time.
The honor is determined through a process involving fellow coaches, who nominate and vote on district candidates before the association’s executive committee makes its selections.
Macaulay had nominated an area coach she respected earlier in the season. Although she didn’t know precisely how the final decision was made, she appreciated receiving recognition from others familiar with the demands of the profession.
“You don’t really get recognized unless other coaches are throwing your name into the hat as well,” she said.
The award followed a season in which five seniors had graduated from a 25-5 team that failed to advance beyond the sectional tournament in 2025. Avery Little and Taryn Wilson were the only returning seniors, while junior Ayela Hoehn assumed much of the setting responsibility and her twin sister, Kenna, moved into the libero position.
The Vikings finished 22-8, winning six of nine five-set matches. Two came on the same afternoon in the sectional tournament, when North Posey recovered from a 9-2 fifth-set deficit against Perry Central before overcoming a two-set deficit and surviving two match points against Forest Park.
For Macaulay, the recognition also acknowledged the demands of coaching that rarely receive attention.
“We put a lot of time and effort, and there’s lots of sleepless nights that people are not aware of,” she said.
Macaulay specifically thanked North Posey principal Sean Fisher and athletic director Waylon Schenk for their support, crediting both with helping her succeed as a coach.
The first person she called about the award was her husband, who also coaches and understands how deeply the results can affect those responsible for a team.
“We take the losses harder than anybody else, and the wins go to the players. They’re the ones that win the game,” Macaulay said. “But this one feels like a win for coaches.”

.png)
